Categories
In Reading Color

The Case For More Black Elves, News, and New Releases

Welcome to In Reading Color, a space where we focus on literature by and about people of color.

In tired, are-you-still-on this news, there has been backlash against the diverse casting in the new Lord of the Rings series. There’s a Black dwarf princess and an Afro-Latine elf, and the racists are big madT. I have to admit my… I don’t know, maybe I should refer to it as naïveté, because I really thought people were over this. I mean, we are in the middle of a pandemic still, and there are disaster-fires of various severity still going on all over the world. People are still taking the time to be mad about a fictional world not having all white people in it, though. I can’t.

l remember years ago when the Hunger Games movies were coming out and people were mad that Rue was cast as a Black girl, even though she was Black in the books. More recently, John Boyega in Star Wars and Halle Bailey as the future Little Mermaid also ruffled racists’ feathers. The logic against diverse casting in a lot of these complaints always seems to be that these non-white characters wouldn’t have existed in middle earth/space/undersea. All of the other non-realistic elements— like the existence of mermaids, magical elves, sci-fi wars in space, etc.— are perfectly acceptable, though. Plus, these people never seem to keep that same energy for when white people are playing Black or other non-white characters. Just say you don’t want to see non-white people and go.

Another argument against swapping races for TV and movie adaptations is simply that it’s not canon, which may be tempting for some to accept as a valid argument. That is, until you start accounting for all the times white actors have played non-white characters and no one batted an eye. This article by HuffPost is a few years old, so it doesn’t have more recent examples, but the side-by-side comparisons make such a good case. Non-white erasure has been so prominent in Hollywood that giving a few actors who aren’t white the chance to play traditionally white characters is just the beginning of fixing a system that is so dangerously discriminatory.

Still, there are some people of color who think that instead of putting non-white characters where there were none before, we should just produce more works by authors and screenwriters of color. I personally think we need to do both. We need that different perspective that comes from non-white writers, but we should also continue to diversify previously non-diverse scripts and books because there is still discrimination— that has been going on for decades— concerning whose scripts get chosen. What do you think?

A Few New Books Out

Middle Grade

A Comb of Wishes by Lisa Stringfellow

Rima’s Rebellion: Courage in a Time of Tyranny by Margarita Engle 

Young Adult

Cold by Mariko Tamaki

Cherish Farrah by Bethany C. Morrow

cover of Cherish Farrah by Bethany C. Morrow

Lulu and Milagro’s Search for Clarity by Angela Velez

Ophelia After All by Racquel Marie

Sunny G’s Series of Rash Decisions by Navdeep Singh Dhillon 

You Truly Assumed by Laila Sabreen

Reclaim the Stars: 17 Tales Across Realms & Space by Zoraida Cordova

The Chandler Legacies by Abdi Nazemian

Make sure to get your own Read Harder Book Journal from Book Riot to track your reading for the year!

Adult

Moon Witch, Spider King by Marlon James cover

God Is a Black Woman by Christena Cleveland

Homicide and Halo-Halo by Mia P. Manansala

Jawbone by Mónica Ojed

Nobody’s Magic by Destiny O. Birdsong

Moon Witch, Spider King by Marlon James

The Almond in the Apricot by Sara Goudarzi 

Don’t forget you can get three free audiobooks at Audiobooks.com with a free trial!

A Little Sumn Extra

The cast of Washington Black looks really good so far!

Take it back to the ’90s with these series you should read this year

Glory Edim Launches Well-Read Black Girl Series

Jaime Herndon reread Fahrenheit 451 and compares it to the current state of book banning and censorship that’s going on

Here are some South Asian books to read this year

Here are some Affrilachian poetry collections to get into

DC shows its lineup for 2022 movies, one of which is Black Adam, played by The Rock

ZORA NEALE HURSTON bookmark

I’m a sucker for a nice bookmark, and this one featuring Zora Neale Hurston is deliciously vintage. $12

Erika Hardison’s list of bookish Black Etsy shops has a lot of other cute things, like washi tape that has a super kawaii Meg Thee Stallion in cowboy chaps (!!).


Thanks for reading; it’s been cute! If you want to reach out and connect, email me at erica@riotnewmedia.com or tweet at me @erica_eze_. You can find me on the Hey YA podcast with the fab Tirzah Price, as well as in the In The Club newsletter.

Until next week,

-E